Greeley's Trusted Butcher Since Day One

Every Cut Chosen
With Intention

We don't process meat by the calendar — we prepare it by the order. At Carniceria La Preferida, each cut is hand-selected, portioned to your specifications, and ready the same day you walk in.

Visit Our Shop (970) 573-5174
Daily Fresh Cuts
Custom Portioning
Local Sourced
Premium beef cuts displayed on a butcher counter at Carniceria La Preferida
Trusted by Greeley families
Our Story

A Neighborhood
Butcher Shop
You Can Count On

Carniceria La Preferida has served the Greeley community as a dedicated butcher shop and market. We focus on what we do best: providing fresh, quality meats prepared exactly the way you need them.

Whether you're planning a weekend barbecue, a family dinner, or a special celebration, our team helps you select the right cuts and prepares them to your specifications — from whole roasts to thin steaks, ground to order, or custom portions.

Hand-Selected Cuts

Every piece is inspected and prepared with care, not processed on autopilot.

Same-Day Readiness

Orders are prepared the day you need them — no waiting, no compromise on freshness.

Community-Focused

We're part of Greeley. Your satisfaction and trust matter to us every day.

Interior of Carniceria La Preferida butcher counter with fresh meat displays
Close-up of premium beef cuts ready for customer selection
Walk-ins Welcome
What We Offer

Specialty Services
Built Around You

From everyday meals to special occasions, we provide the cuts, preparation, and guidance you need — every time you walk through our doors.

01

Premium Beef Cuts

Ribeyes, sirloins, roasts, and more — graded, inspected, and cut to your preferred thickness and weight.

02

Custom Grinding

Ground beef, burger blends, and specialty mixes prepared fresh to order — choose your fat ratio and texture.

03

Special Orders

Need a specific cut, a certain weight, or a particular preparation? Place a special order and we'll have it ready when you arrive.

04

Poultry & More

Whole chickens, breasts, thighs, and a selection of other proteins — all fresh and available for immediate purchase.

05

Event & Party Orders

Planning a gathering? We'll help you plan the meat selection, portion everything consistently, and prep it all for pickup.

06

Expert Guidance

Not sure which cut works best for your recipe? Our team provides straightforward advice so you get exactly what you need.

Quality Isn't a
Marketing Term
Here — It's a Standard

We source from reputable suppliers and inspect every delivery. If a cut doesn't meet our standards, it doesn't reach the counter. That's the commitment we make to every customer who walks in.

100% Fresh, Never Frozen at Sale
Same Day Preparation & Packaging
Custom Portions to Your Specs
Local Greeley Community Focus
Find Us

Visit
Our Shop

Address

3487 W 10th St
Greeley, CO 80634

Call to Place an Order

Ready to Experience
the Difference?

Stop settling for pre-packaged, unremarkable meat. Come to Carniceria La Preferida and taste what happens when a butcher shop actually cares about every cut.

(970) 573-5174 Get Directions
Is this your business? This is my business